The candidate looks plausible. It is not ready to ship.
You are the engineer accountable for the production launch decision.
The candidate inherits the same failure families you have already seen: instruction authority is loose, execution is too autonomous, graph coordination is heavier than the task earns, and evaluation is still demo-biased. Retrieval and context are not obviously broken, which makes unnecessary changes expensive distractions.
Use at most five engineering changes. Inspect evidence first, repair the highest-leverage cross-layer blockers, replay the candidate, compare attempts, then defend SHIP, BLOCK, or INCONCLUSIVE.
A release score is advisory. Safety vetoes and hard production constraints cannot be averaged away.